MAC Smolder Eye Kohl Review, Swatches and Photos
Oh baby.. You are my dream! You are my nightmare. DREAMS about having you on my eyes. NIGHTMARES about breaking my little piggy bank. I saved all my ice creams, chocolates, samosas, films, books paisa just for you alone. It took many nights to decide about bringing you home or not. Finally I gave you are a warm welcome into my heart and now you are sitting comfortably in my home. That BABY is my favorite MAC Eye Kojl. Since it’s a baby I wanted to give a poetic welcome and my expressions of love too. :) No more poems, lets move on to the review.
Price and Quantity:
Rs.790 for 1.45 gm
My Experience:
I have a love-hate relationship with this product. I love its packaging. Who doesn’t love black? It comes in a standard matte black MAC rectangular box. The pencil is black in color. It is a normal type of pencil that needs to be sharpened. But I think it is quite long when compared to the other pencils. So it can last you for quite a long time.
The texture of this kohl is really smooth and creamy. It glides on eyes like butter, hence no tugging and pulling around eyes. Even though it has a creamy texture it doesn’t break while sharpening. Most importantly, it has that blackest black color that every girl wants.
As it is well pigmented you just need few swipes of this to get a jet black eye. It is not smudge proof actually. If you have watery eyes this is not for you, because it smudges so badly when eyes are rubbed accidentally. But once it settles it stays for a long time. It is not waterproof but water resistant. At the end of the day, it fades but doesn’t give you that raccoon eyes. I wear contact lens and it doesn’t irritate my eyes. Overall, it is not so worth of money but still a decent product.
On My Eyes:
PROS:
- Nice packaging
- The texture is smooth and creamy
- Easy to sharpen, doesn’t break while sharpening
- Blackest black color makes it stand out
- Stays for a whole day if eyes are not rubbed or set with a eye shadow
- Easy to create dramatic smokey eye looks just as the MAC MUA recommends
CONS:
- As you guess, expensive!!!
- Not smudge proof hence smudges a lot on watery eye and if rubbed accidentally
- It is water resistant but not waterproof.
Rating: 3.5/5 (for being expensive, non smudge proof and non waterproof)
Do I Recommend?:
Yes, if you need a jet black kohl to create smokey looks and if you don’t have watery eyes and hyperactive hands. Not to forget if you don’t mind the heavy price tag.
Would I Repurchase?:
No. I cant break my piggy bank again. I think Lakme Eyeconic kajal works better than this.
22 Comments
Jenita Eva
Great Review Swathi :)cant believe such expensive product smudges btw loved ur introductory part :)
Swati Reddy
Thanks Jeni..:)
It smudges like hell on watery eyes.. :(
Lancy
Great review Chinky :) Is that corn flakes? ;;-) Enna vittu saaptiya?
Adi S
I noticed the cornflakes too! So creative :D and Swathika your intro cracked me up :D nice review! I use eyeconic and I’m in no mood to change that ;)
Lancy
I ll never compromise with my ice creams and candies :P I am a huge cornetto lover..
Swati Reddy
Thanks dear..
Strawberry corn flakes..:P
Ne matm mutton biryani sapta la…
Swati Reddy
Haa :) Thanks Adi..
I like Lakme Eyeconic too ..I think its the best ..
Swati Reddy
I compromised for this..
I love everything in icecreams..Kulfi is my fav :)
Ll get you a cornetto for sure Lancy..:):D
Lancy
Thank you soooo much :) Get me Kulfi too :P I love kulfi with crunchy almonds.
Swati Reddy
Podhum Lan..:)
Romba overa pogudu:D
Lancy
Lol seri :P Food blog la recent post paaru
Radha Krishnakumar
Lol Swathi I loved your intro more than review :p
Swati Reddy
Surprise.. Thanks a lot Rads :)
I wanted to write more than this :P
Gowthami Sundaram
Nicee review :) and the clicks are too gud :)
Swati Reddy
Thanks Gowmi sweety :)
ashley kay
So cute Swathika..Wanna get this baby..wish it could have been waterproof and smudge proof…
Swati Reddy
Thanku Ash..
Get if you can bear with this troublesome baby :P:D
ashley kay
Im a cornetto lover too lancy…:)
Swati Reddy
Ill get you one too..:D
Arshita Dhara
very nice review…so creative, Swati…:)
dharu
oh…piggy bank ha cute…..so sad a product from a brand like mac is so bad..:(
Sunshine Beauty
Great review